Report: Premium Hikes for Top Medicare Drug Plans

By RICARDO ALONSO-ZALDIVAR

WASHINGTON (AP) – Millions of seniors enrolled in some of the most popular Medicare prescription drug plans face double-digit premium hikes next year if they don’t shop for a better deal, says a private firm that analyzes the highly competitive market.

Seven of the top 10 prescription plans are raising their premiums by 11 percent to 23 percent, according to a report this week by Avalere Health.

It’s a reality check on a stream of upbeat Medicare announcements from the Obama administration, all against the backdrop of a hard-fought election. In August, officials had announced that the average premium for basic prescription drug coverage will stay the same in 2013, at $30 a month.

The administration’s number is accurate as an overall indicator for the entire market, but not very helpful to consumers individually since it doesn’t reflect price swings in the real world.

“The average senior is going to benefit by carefully scrutinizing their situation, because every year the market changes,” Avalere President Dan Mendelson said. Avalere crunched the numbers based on bid documents that the plans submitted to Medicare.

The report found premium increases for all top 10 prescription drug plans, known as PDPs. However, the most popular plan – AARP MedicareRx Preferred – is only going up 57 cents per month nationally, to $40.42 from the current $39.85.

President Barack Obama’s health care law does not appear to be the cause of the increases. Indeed, the law is improving the prescription benefit by gradually closing a coverage gap called the “doughnut hole,” which catches people with high drug costs. Instead, the price hikes appear to be driven by market dynamics, and some insurers are introducing new low-premium options to gain a competitive advantage on plans that are raising their prices.

The seven plans with double-digit premium increases were: the Humana (HUM) Walmart (WMT)-Preferred Rx Plan (23 percent); First Health (CVH) Part D Premier (18 percent); First Health Part D Value Plus (17 percent); Cigna (CI) Medicare Rx Plan One (15 percent); Express Scripts (ESRX) Medicare-Value (13 percent); the HealthSpring (HS) Drug Plan (12 percent); and Humana Enhanced (11 percent).

Another two plans in the top 10 also had single-digit increases. They were the SilverScript Basic (8 percent) and WellCare (WCG) Classic (3 percent).

On the plus side for consumers, a major new low-cost plan entered the market. Premiums for the AARP MedicareRx Saver Plus Plan will average $15 a month nationally, although it won’t be available everywhere. That’s $3.50 less than the current low-cost leader, the Humana Walmart plan, whose premiums are rising to $18.50.

The new AARP plan is run by UnitedHealth Group Inc. (UNH), the nation’s largest health insurance company. United pays AARP for the right to use its name on a range of Medicare insurance products, a successful business strategy that has proven lucrative for both partners. When Humana and Walmart teamed up to offer their low-cost plan in 2011, United felt the competition.

“There is a real focus on the premium in this market,” Mendelson said. “If a plan fields an offering with a low premium, it knows it can capture a significant number of customers.”

Medicare spokesman Brian Cook did not dispute the Avalere estimates. “We continue to encourage seniors to shop around and find the plan that works best for them,” he said.

Medicare’s open enrollment season starts Oct. 15, and beneficiaries have a wide variety of choices of taxpayer-subsidized private prescription plans. Seniors and family members can use the online Medicare Plan Finder to input individual prescription lists and find plans in their area that cover them.

adsonar_placementId=1505951;adsonar_pid=1990767;adsonar_ps=-1;adsonar_zw=242;adsonar_zh=252;adsonar_jv=’ads.tw.adsonar.com’;
About 90 percent of Medicare’s nearly 50 million beneficiaries have some form of drug coverage, with more than 17 million enrolled in private plans through the prescription drug program. Of those, 14 million are in the top 10 plans.

The Avalare numbers, released Monday, do have one silver lining for the Obama administration. When the projections are tweaked to account for seniors switching to lower-cost coverage, premiums for 2013 are likely to remain steady.

Separately, the administration recently announced that average premiums for Medicare Advantage insurance plans will barely inch up next year on average, while enrollment in the private medical plans will continue to rise. Many Medicare Advantage plans also combine prescription drug coverage in one package deal.

But the biggest premium announcement is yet to come.

Virtually all seniors pay the Part B premium for outpatient care, including those with traditional Medicare as well as those in private plans. Currently $99.90 a month, the Part B premium is expected to rise by about $7 for 2013, according to the government’s own projections.

According to a study conducted by the Department of Health and Human Services and the nonpartisan Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, Kentucky will be the biggest winner in the proposed Medicaid expansion. Currently, 16.1% of Kentuckians under 65 are uninsured. The new Medicaid rules will reduce the number of poor people without insurance by 57.1%.

Kentucky voted for John McCain in 2008.

Biggest Winners from Obamacare: 1. Kentucky

Currently, 18.7% of Oregonians under 65 and 12.8% under 18 don’t have health insurance. Under the proposed Medicare rules, the number of poor people without insurance will drop by 56.7%.

Oregon voted for Obama in 2008.

Biggest Winners from Obamacare: 2. Oregon

Times are tough in the Mountain State: 18.6% of West Virginians under 65 are uninsured. If the state adopts the Medicare rule change, the number of uninsured poor people will drop by 56.7%.

West Virginia voted for McCain in 2008.

Biggest Winners from Obamacare: 3. West Virginia

South Carolina Gov. Nikki Hailey has already vowed to reject the Medicare expansion. Her state has one of the highest percentages of uninsured citizens: 19.9% of South Carolinians under age 65 don’t have insurance. 12.7% of children under 18 are also uninsured. Under the proposed new Medicare rules, the percentage of poor people without health insurance would drop by 56.4%.

South Carolina voted for McCain in 2008. It’s also where the first shot was fired in the Civil War.

Biggest Winners from Obamacare: 4. South Carolina

Like South Carolina, Mississippi has also announced its plans to reject the Medicare expansion. And, like South Carolina, it could especially use the health care funds: 20.2% of Mississippians under 65 and 12.7% of those under 18 don’t have insurance. Under the new rules, 54.9% of those poor people currently without health insurance would get it.

Mississippi voted for McCain in 2008.

Biggest Winners from Obamacare: 5. Mississippi

At the other end of the scale, Delaware is one of the states that stands to benefit least from a Medicare expansion. Only 11.8% of people under 65 in the state are uninsured. Still, with the new rules, the number of uninsured people under the poverty line would drop by 15.9%.

Delaware voted for Obama in 2008.

States with the Least to Gain: 5. Delaware

With an uninsured population of just 13.3%, New York also won’t get much out of the new Medicare expansion. Even so, the number of poor people without insurance in the Empire State will drop by 14.8%.

New York voted for Obama in 2008.

States with the Least to Gain: 4. New York

Arizona has one of the highest percentages of uninsured citizens: 21.2% of people under 65 and 16.2% under 18 don’t have insurance. Even so, the Medicare expansion won’t help the Grand Canyon state all that much: it will only reduce the number of poor people without health care by 13.6%.

Arizona voted for McCain in 2008.

States with the Least to Gain: 3. Arizona

Vermont has one of the lowest uninsured percentages in the country: Only 10.4% of its citizens don’t have health coverage. Not surprisingly, the Medicare expansion won’t help that much — it will only reduce the number of uninsured poor people by 10.2%.

Vermont voted for Obama in 2008.

Photo: Skeddy in NYC, Flickr.com

States with the Least to Gain: 2. Vermont

Thanks in large part to Mitt Romney’s statewide health insurance program, Massachusetts is the best-insured state in the nation. Only 4.6% of citizens under 65 and 2.1% under 18 aren’t insured. Not surprisingly, the Bay State will also benefit least from the Medicare expansion: it will only reduce the number of poor people without insurance by 10.2%.

Massachusetts voted for Obama in 2008.

States with the Least to Gain: 1. Massachusetts

8 Things to Never Keep in Your Wallet

World’s Hottest Billionaire Offspring

10 Brands That Will Disappear in 2013

7 Reasons Best Buy Won’t Be Around in 7 Years

The 10 Most Dangerous Cities